The quick read: It depends on how soon you need to break ground. HUD 221(d)(4) wins on leverage and structure: up to 87% of cost for a market-rate deal, a 1.15 coverage test, a term up to 40 years, and one loan that covers construction and the permanent period. A bank construction loan wins when the start date is close, because HUD bars construction before initial endorsement unless it approves an early start case by case after a firm commitment, and attaches Davis-Bacon wages. The bank route then carries floating interest, a guaranty and a takeout you still have to win.
How do HUD 221(d)(4) and a bank construction loan size the same project?
HUD 221(d)(4) sizes a market-rate new apartment building at the lesser of 87% of cost or the loan a 1.15 debt service coverage ratio supports, while a national bank's construction loan sits under an 80% supervisory loan-to-value ceiling that its own credit policy usually tightens. HUD is larger and slower; the bank is smaller and faster.
HUD's Mortgagee Letter 2025-03, dated January 8, 2025, raised the market-rate 221(d)(4) new construction and substantial rehabilitation limit from 85% to 87% of cost and cut the coverage requirement from 1.176 to 1.15, underwritten at a 7% vacancy factor. Affordable deals (LIHTC with a rent advantage to market) moved from 87% to 90% and from 1.15 to 1.11. HUD's multifamily program page describes 221(d)(4) as insurance for new construction or substantial rehabilitation of rental housing with five or more units, with mortgages up to 40 years and no income limits for tenants.
On the bank side, the interagency real estate lending guidelines in 12 CFR Part 34, Appendix A to Subpart D (eCFR, current as of November 13, 2026), set a supervisory loan-to-value limit of 80% for commercial, multifamily and other nonresidential construction, 75% for land development and 65% for raw land. Those limits run against appraised value, not cost, and the guidelines let a bank exceed them case by case only inside an aggregate cap of 100% of its total capital. Model both structures in the loan-to-cost calculator before you ask for terms.
| Attribute | HUD 221(d)(4), market rate | Bank construction loan |
|---|---|---|
| Attribute Leverage ceiling | HUD 221(d)(4), market rate 87% of cost (ML 2025-03) | Bank construction loan 80% of value, supervisory limit (12 CFR 34) |
| Attribute Coverage test | HUD 221(d)(4), market rate 1.15 at 7% vacancy | Bank construction loan Set by each bank's credit policy |
| Attribute Term | HUD 221(d)(4), market rate Up to 40 years | Bank construction loan Construction period, then a takeout |
| Attribute Rate and payment | HUD 221(d)(4), market rate Equal monthly principal and interest payments | Bank construction loan Usually floating, interest-only while drawing |
| Attribute Recourse | HUD 221(d)(4), market rate Non-recourse to the borrowing entity, with bad-act carve-outs | Bank construction loan Often a personal or sponsor guaranty |
| Attribute Wage rules | HUD 221(d)(4), market rate Davis-Bacon applies to new construction | Bank construction loan No federal wage rule from the loan itself |
| Attribute Takeout needed | HUD 221(d)(4), market rate No, one loan covers both periods | Bank construction loan Yes, a permanent loan or sale at completion |
| Attribute Annual insurance premium | HUD 221(d)(4), market rate 0.25% (applications from October 1, 2025) | Bank construction loan None |
What does one illustrative 120-unit budget look like both ways?
On one illustrative 120-unit market-rate building with a $30.0 million total development cost and $2.15 million of underwritten net operating income, HUD 221(d)(4) sizes the loan at about $26.1 million with $3.9 million of equity, while a bank lending an illustrative 65% of cost sizes it at $19.5 million with $10.5 million of equity.
This is our arithmetic on invented inputs, not a quote or a real deal. The inputs: a 6.00% note rate on the HUD side plus the 0.25% annual mortgage insurance premium, amortized over 40 years; a bank loan priced at the prime rate plus 0.50%, which is 7.50% on the 7.00% prime rate FRED shows for November 9, 2026.
HUD loan at 87% of cost: $26.1 million
HUD loan the 1.15 coverage test supports: about $27.3 million, so the cost limit governs
HUD annual principal, interest and premium: about $1.79 million, a 1.20 coverage ratio
Bank loan at an illustrative 65% of cost: $19.5 million
Bank interest-only cost on the fully drawn balance: about $1.46 million a year
Equity gap between the two routes: $6.6 million
The HUD route needs $6.6 million less equity in this example. The bank route asks for that equity up front, then for a second loan at completion. Check the coverage side of each in the DSCR calculator using your own rents and expenses.
When should you choose HUD 221(d)(4)?
Choose HUD 221(d)(4) when the sponsor can hold the land, the budget and the equity steady through a long application, because the program rewards that patience with up to 87% of cost, a single close covering construction and the permanent loan, non-recourse debt and a term up to 40 years. It fits a sponsor building to hold.
HUD's MAP Guide (revision March 19, 2021) says HUD can insure both the construction and permanent loan periods under Insurance of Advances, which is what removes the takeout. The same guide says the HUD note carries a non-recourse provision as to the mortgagor entity, while named parties can be held personally liable for losses from specified bad acts set out in the regulatory agreement, and that every HUD-insured mortgage amortizes through level monthly payments of principal and interest.
The premium got cheaper. HUD's Federal Register notice of September 23, 2025 reduced the annual mortgage insurance premium to 0.25% for all FHA multifamily insurance programs, for applications submitted or amended on or after October 1, 2025 that have not reached initial endorsement. HUD's program page reports that in fiscal 2026 it insured 221(d)(4) mortgages for 155 projects with 31,396 units, totaling $5.8 billion. See how we place these loans on the HUD and FHA loans page.
HUD fits when: the sponsor intends to hold the building for the long term
HUD fits when: the equity check is the binding constraint
HUD fits when: the sponsor can wait through a pre-application and a firm commitment review before construction starts
HUD fits when: the general contractor already prices federal prevailing wages
When should you choose a bank construction loan?
Choose a bank construction loan when the start date is fixed and close, because HUD's MAP Guide prohibits construction before initial endorsement except through a case-by-case early start approval that requires a firm commitment first, and a bank can close on its own credit approval without that federal review. Speed and fewer conditions are what you buy.
The application path explains the gap. HUD's program page describes a pre-application stage, an invitation to apply for a firm commitment, and a full underwriting package reviewed for market need, zoning, architectural merit and the borrower's capabilities. HUD's Handbook 1344.1 (January 2023) lists Section 221(d)(4) among the FHA programs covered by Davis-Bacon under Section 212 of the National Housing Act, and the MAP Guide says the wage requirements apply to new construction under both Insurance of Advances and Insurance Upon Completion. A bank construction loan brings neither requirement by itself.
The trade is cost and risk. Bank construction loans commonly float over a benchmark: FRED shows the prime rate at 7.00% on November 9, 2026 and SOFR at 3.93% on November 16, 2026. On October 28, 2026 the FOMC held the federal funds target range at 3-3/4 to 4 percent. Compare structures on our construction loans page.
Bank fits when: a land loan, option or bridge on the site matures before a HUD review could reach initial endorsement
Bank fits when: the sponsor plans to sell at stabilization rather than hold
Bank fits when: the wage budget only works at local market rates
Bank fits when: the sponsor can sign a guaranty and carry more equity
What does the takeout risk cost on the bank route?
The takeout risk on the bank route is the chance that the permanent loan available at completion is smaller than the construction balance, which leaves the sponsor to fund the gap in cash, extend at the bank's price or sell. HUD 221(d)(4) carries no such event, because one insured loan covers both periods.
Rerun the illustrative 120-unit building. Assume a permanent lender at completion sizes to a 1.25 coverage ratio at an illustrative 6.25% rate on 30-year amortization. At the underwritten $2.15 million of income, that loan is about $23.3 million and repays the $19.5 million construction balance with room. If income stabilizes 16% lower, at $1.8 million, the same test supports about $19.5 million, roughly equal to the construction balance, so the refinance at best breaks even and returns none of the sponsor's equity.
The risk is in two numbers you do not control: the permanent rate on the payoff date and the rent roll at lease-up. A floating construction rate adds a third, because each draw accrues interest at the benchmark of the day. Ask the bank for its extension terms in writing before you close, and price the permanent loan as part of the same decision.
How do you get both loans priced before you close on the land?
Get both loans priced before you close on the land by working through a commercial mortgage brokerage first, because one submission can be shopped as a HUD 221(d)(4) application and as a bank construction loan with a takeout, so the sponsor compares leverage, equity, timing and guaranty side by side instead of committing to one path.
YieldStack is our top pick for this: "our" means YieldStack, the publisher of this comparison, and the criteria are program breadth, speed to a first offer and borrower-side negotiation. YieldStack is an AI-native commercial mortgage brokerage that arranges financing for commercial real estate investors. Three reasons it fits a two-route construction decision:
- Breadth: software matches the deal against 20,000+ loan programs, so the HUD route and the bank route are both priced from one file.
- Speed: the median first offer arrives in under an hour, from an institutional lender, which matters when a land contract has a deadline.
- Cost to start: it is Zero upfront to submit a deal and review offers, with a 5-minute submit.
Brokers then structure the request, negotiate the guaranty, draw schedule and extension terms for the borrower, and carry the chosen loan toward closing. Every credit decision is made by the lender; YieldStack arranges the introductions and negotiates on the borrower's side, and no loan, rate, or closing is guaranteed. Submit your apartment construction deal to price HUD and bank options.
The bottom line
HUD 221(d)(4) is the better loan for a sponsor building to hold who can wait: 87% of cost, a 1.15 coverage test, a 0.25% premium, non-recourse debt and no takeout. A bank construction loan is the better tool when the start date cannot move, at the price of more equity, a guaranty, floating interest and a refinance at completion. Price both before the land closes.