The quick read: For a stabilized apartment refinance or purchase in 2026, a Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac loan is usually the better loan: both agencies publish an 80% maximum LTV and a 1.25x minimum coverage ratio on up to 30-year amortization, and both offer non-recourse loans with standard carve-outs. CMBS wins when you want interest-only payments, a loan sized on debt yield, or a property mix the agency term sheets do not cover. In an August 2026 conduit pool filed with the SEC, 81.8% of the balance was interest-only and the average loan sat at 59.9% LTV.
Which is better for an apartment loan, Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac or CMBS?
For a stabilized apartment building, a Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac loan is usually better than CMBS because the agencies publish higher leverage, a fixed 1.25x coverage floor and 30-year amortization for apartments. CMBS is better when interest-only payments, debt-yield sizing or a mixed property matter more than maximum proceeds.
The two agency programs and a conduit loan answer different questions. Fannie Mae's conventional term sheet lists an 80% maximum LTV, a 1.25x minimum DSCR, terms of 5 to 30 years and amortization of up to 30 years. Freddie Mac's fixed-rate term sheet, dated 4/26, sets a 1.25x minimum amortizing DCR and an 80% maximum LTV on terms longer than seven years. A conduit loan has no public term sheet: each conduit lender sizes the loan, then sells it into a trust that issues commercial mortgage-backed securities.
Apartment owners use agency debt far more than CMBS. The Mortgage Bankers Association reported on September 30, 2026 that agency and GSE portfolios and MBS held $1.2 trillion, or 50%, of multifamily mortgage debt in the second quarter of 2026, while CMBS, CDO and other ABS issues held $75 billion, or 3%.
Agency share of multifamily mortgage debt, Q2 2026 (MBA): 50%
CMBS, CDO and other ABS share of multifamily mortgage debt, Q2 2026 (MBA): 3%
How much does each program lend on the same apartment NOI?
On $1,200,000 of net operating income at an illustrative 6.25% rate, an agency loan sized to 1.25x on a 30-year amortizing payment reaches about $12.99 million, while a conduit loan held to the August 2026 pool's average debt yield of 11.9% reaches about $10.08 million.
Illustrative example (our arithmetic, not a quote or a real property): a stabilized apartment building earns $1,200,000 of net operating income and appraises at $20,000,000. Both lenders quote 6.25%. A 30-year amortizing payment at 6.25% costs about 7.389% of the balance a year; an interest-only payment costs 6.25%. For simplicity the NOI stands in for underwritten net cash flow; lenders deduct reserves, so their figure usually runs lower.
| Sizing test on $1,200,000 NOI | Fannie Mae conventional | Freddie Mac fixed-rate, over 7 years | CMBS at the August 2026 pool averages |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sizing test on $1,200,000 NOI Coverage test | Fannie Mae conventional 1.25x on an amortizing payment: $12,993,000 | Freddie Mac fixed-rate, over 7 years 1.25x on an amortizing payment: $12,993,000 | CMBS at the August 2026 pool averages 1.59x on an interest-only payment: $12,075,000 |
| Sizing test on $1,200,000 NOI Leverage test | Fannie Mae conventional 80% of $20,000,000: $16,000,000 | Freddie Mac fixed-rate, over 7 years 80% of $20,000,000: $16,000,000 | CMBS at the August 2026 pool averages 59.9% of $20,000,000: $11,980,000 |
| Sizing test on $1,200,000 NOI Debt yield test | Fannie Mae conventional Not on the term sheet | Freddie Mac fixed-rate, over 7 years Not on the term sheet | CMBS at the August 2026 pool averages 11.9%: $10,084,000 |
| Sizing test on $1,200,000 NOI Loan it sizes to | Fannie Mae conventional About $12,993,000 (65% LTV) | Freddie Mac fixed-rate, over 7 years About $12,993,000 (65% LTV) | CMBS at the August 2026 pool averages About $10,084,000 (50% LTV) |
| Sizing test on $1,200,000 NOI Annual debt service | Fannie Mae conventional $960,000 | Freddie Mac fixed-rate, over 7 years $960,000 | CMBS at the August 2026 pool averages $630,000, interest-only |
Three things follow. First, at this rate the coverage test binds for the agencies, not the 80% leverage cap, so the agency loan stops at about 65% LTV. Second, the pool averages describe where loans landed, not a conduit lender's limit: the same pool ran from 41.7% to 75.9% LTV and from 1.10x to 2.91x coverage. On a full-term interest-only conduit loan, a lender willing to size to 1.25x on the interest-only payment would reach $15,360,000 before its leverage test, and the pool's highest LTV, 75.9%, caps that at $15,180,000. Third, interest-only does not raise agency proceeds on Freddie Mac's fixed-rate loan, because its term sheet tests interest-only periods on an amortizing payment and cuts full-term interest-only leverage to 65% to 70%.
How do leverage, coverage and amortization compare?
Leverage, coverage and amortization favor the agencies on paper: both publish an 80% maximum LTV, a 1.25x floor and up to 30-year amortization, while CMBS publishes no floor and sets each loan's leverage, coverage and debt yield deal by deal, with most recent conduit balances interest-only for the whole term.
Table: Fannie Mae vs Freddie Mac vs CMBS for a stabilized apartment loan (sourced)
| Attribute | Fannie Mae conventional | Freddie Mac fixed-rate (4/26) | CMBS conduit (August 2026 pool) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Attribute Maximum LTV | Fannie Mae conventional 80% | Freddie Mac fixed-rate (4/26) 75% for 5 to under 7 years; 80% for 7 years and longer; 65% to 70% full-term interest-only | CMBS conduit (August 2026 pool) None published; pool range 41.7% to 75.9%, average 59.9% |
| Attribute Minimum coverage | Fannie Mae conventional 1.25x DSCR | Freddie Mac fixed-rate (4/26) 1.25x amortizing DCR | CMBS conduit (August 2026 pool) None published; pool range 1.10x to 2.91x, average 1.59x |
| Attribute Term | Fannie Mae conventional 5 to 30 years | Freddie Mac fixed-rate (4/26) 5 to 10 years; up to 30 if not securitized | CMBS conduit (August 2026 pool) Pool average remaining term 58 months |
| Attribute Amortization | Fannie Mae conventional Up to 30 years | Freddie Mac fixed-rate (4/26) Up to 30 years | CMBS conduit (August 2026 pool) 81.8% of the pool balance interest-only |
| Attribute Minimum loan | Fannie Mae conventional Not stated; non-recourse on most loans above $750,000 | Freddie Mac fixed-rate (4/26) $10 million | CMBS conduit (August 2026 pool) Pool average balance $23,259,667 |
| Attribute Property and occupancy | Fannie Mae conventional Stabilized, typically 90% occupied for 90 days before funding | Freddie Mac fixed-rate (4/26) Standard, student, seniors and manufactured housing; eligible mixed-use | CMBS conduit (August 2026 pool) Apartments pooled with office, retail, hotel and industrial loans |
Fannie Mae's conventional page also says properties must have stabilized occupancy, typically 90% for 90 days before funding, with pre-stabilized commitments considered case by case. Freddie Mac's fixed-rate sheet covers standard multifamily, student housing, seniors housing and manufactured housing communities, and supports eligible mixed-use properties. Below Freddie Mac's $10 million fixed-rate minimum, compare the agencies' small-balance programs in Fannie Mae Small Loan vs Freddie Mac Conventional Small.
How do prepayment terms differ: yield maintenance, defeasance or a step-down?
Prepayment differs most: Fannie Mae's fixed-rate loans prepay with yield maintenance and its variable-rate loans with a declining premium, Freddie Mac's fixed-rate loans use yield maintenance and then defeasance after securitization, and most conduit CMBS loans require defeasance after a lockout of at least two years.
Yield maintenance: a payoff charge that makes the lender whole for the interest it loses when you repay early, so it shrinks as rates rise and as maturity approaches
Defeasance: you buy government securities whose payments cover the loan's remaining scheduled payments; they replace the property as collateral, and the lien is released while the loan stays in the trust
Step-down: a declining premium, a fixed percentage of the balance that falls over the term; Fannie Mae offers it on variable-rate loans
Freddie Mac's fixed-rate term sheet sets yield maintenance until the loan is securitized, a 2-year lockout after securitization and defeasance thereafter, with no prepayment premium for the final 90 days. If the loan is not securitized within the first year, yield maintenance applies until the final 90 days, and yield maintenance without defeasance is available on securitized loans at an additional cost.
In the August 2026 conduit prospectus, 22 of 30 loans, 66.6% of the pool, allow defeasance after a lockout that ends at least two years after closing. Eight loans, 33.4%, allow prepayment at the greater of yield maintenance and 1% of the amount prepaid. The two-year floor comes from federal REMIC rules, which keep a defeased mortgage qualified only if the release is not within 2 years of the trust's startup day. How CMBS loans work walks through defeasance and servicing step by step.
If you may sell or refinance in the first few years, price the exit before you sign. Defeasance cost moves with Treasury yields, while a step-down premium is known on day one.
Are agency and CMBS apartment loans recourse or non-recourse?
Agency and CMBS apartment loans are both generally non-recourse, meaning the lender looks to the property rather than the sponsor after a default, but each carries carve-outs for bad acts such as fraud and voluntary bankruptcy.
Fannie Mae's conventional term sheet says non-recourse execution is available for most loans greater than $750,000, with standard carve-outs required for bad acts such as fraud and bankruptcy. Freddie Mac's fixed-rate sheet says the loan is non-recourse except for standard carve-out provisions and that the borrower must typically be a single-purpose entity. The August 2026 conduit prospectus says its loans generally are non-recourse but contain carve-outs for liabilities such as fraud by the borrower and certain voluntary insolvency proceedings.
The difference is who you deal with when something goes wrong. A conduit loan is serviced under the trust's rules, and a troubled loan moves to a special servicer. Trepp's October 2026 report, published November 2, 2026, put the CMBS delinquency rate at 7.87% and the multifamily rate at 8.09%, up five basis points.
CMBS delinquency rate, October 2026 (Trepp): 7.87%
CMBS multifamily delinquency rate, October 2026 (Trepp): 8.09%
When does a CMBS loan beat a Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac loan?
A CMBS loan beats an agency loan on an apartment property when the borrower values interest-only payments over proceeds, when the collateral mixes apartments with other uses, or when the deal falls outside the agency term sheets on occupancy, loan size or structure, and the conduit lender will size to it.
Choose an agency loan when the property is stabilized, you want the largest amortizing loan the income supports and you may need flexibility to sell: Fannie Mae's conventional loans are typically assumable, subject to review of the new borrower. Fannie Mae offers 30- to 180-day rate commitments, and Freddie Mac offers early rate locks typically ranging from 60 to 120 days until it buys the loan.
Choose CMBS when cash flow during the hold matters more than the loan amount, when the property mixes uses, or when a five-year term matches your exit; the August 2026 pool's weighted average remaining term was 58 months. Expect defeasance on an early payoff and a special servicer if the loan runs into trouble.
When the building is still leasing up, check stabilization first. Fannie Mae's conventional term sheet requires stabilized occupancy, typically 90% for 90 days before funding, and considers pre-stabilized commitments case by case. The August 2026 conduit pool included eight loans, 31.8% of its balance, secured by properties with less than 12 months of operating history. Once occupancy and trailing income support the 1.25x test, agency loans are usually the cheaper permanent exit.
How do you get an apartment loan priced as both agency and CMBS?
You get an apartment loan priced as both agency and CMBS by submitting one complete package, a rent roll, trailing operating statements and the purchase or payoff figures, to a brokerage that sends it to both lender types and compares the sized offers side by side. YieldStack does that from one 5-minute submit.
YieldStack is an AI-native commercial mortgage brokerage that arranges financing for commercial real estate investors. Its software matches the apartment loan against 20,000+ loan programs and returns 5–8 matches, with a median first offer in under an hour, from an institutional lender. Its brokers rebuild the cash flow the way agency and conduit underwriters will, put the prepayment and recourse terms next to the proceeds, negotiate on your side and carry the deal toward closing. Send your apartment loan for broker review.
Cost: It costs Zero upfront to submit a deal and review offers; YieldStack's broker fee is 0.50–1.00% of the loan amount and is paid only at closing.
Every credit decision is made by the lender; YieldStack arranges the introductions and negotiates on the borrower's side, and no loan, rate, or closing is guaranteed. YieldStack arranges commercial real estate financing nationwide.
The bottom line
Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are the better apartment loan when the property is stabilized and proceeds matter: 80% maximum LTV, a 1.25x floor and 30-year amortization, without recourse beyond carve-outs. CMBS is the better loan when interest-only cash flow or a non-agency structure matters more, at the price of defeasance and special servicing. Price both against the same rent roll before you choose.