The quick read: It depends on loan size and fee tolerance. SBA 504 is the cheaper, lower-equity route for most rural owner-occupied buildings: a fixed-rate CDC piece, 10% down in the standard case and terms up to 25 years, but the 504 piece caps at $5 million, or $5.5 million for a small manufacturer. USDA Business and Industry (B&I) wins when the project is too large for that cap or needs a term up to 40 years, at the price of a 3% upfront guarantee fee and 0.55% a year, and, with a narrow exception under 7 CFR 5001.105(b)(15)(i), only on a site outside towns of more than 50,000 people.
A commercial mortgage brokerage can price both programs from one file; the section on getting both priced at once, below, explains how.
How do B&I and 504 split the loan on the same building?
B&I and 504 split the loan on the same building in opposite ways: a B&I loan is one lender loan with a USDA guarantee on 80% or 85% of it, while a 504 project stacks a senior lender loan, a CDC second lien and the borrower's cash, so the 504 borrower carries two notes and less equity.
USDA Rural Development's B&I page (modified June 25, 2026) says that for loans approved in fiscal year 2026, applications requesting less than $5,000,000 receive an 85 percent guarantee and applications of $5,000,000 or more receive 80 percent. The lender applies, the lender sets the terms with USDA concurrence, and the borrower sees one loan.
A 504 project has three layers. SBA's 504 page (modified October 28, 2026) says 504 loans come exclusively through Certified Development Companies (CDCs), which originate them in collaboration with a senior lender. Under 13 CFR 120.920 (eCFR, current as of November 13, 2026), the third-party loans must total at least as much as the 504 loan, and the 504 loan usually takes a second lien on the project property. Under 13 CFR 120.910, the borrower contributes at least 10% of project cost in the standard case, 15% for a business operating two years or less or a limited or single purpose building, and 20% when both apply.
| Attribute | USDA B&I guaranteed loan | SBA 504 loan |
|---|---|---|
| Attribute Loan structure | USDA B&I guaranteed loan One lender loan, USDA guarantees part | SBA 504 loan Senior lender loan plus CDC second lien |
| Attribute Size limit | USDA B&I guaranteed loan No maximum stated on USDA's program page | SBA 504 loan 504 piece: $5.0M, or $5.5M for small manufacturers |
| Attribute Maximum term | USDA B&I guaranteed loan Up to 40 years | SBA 504 loan 10, 20 or 25 years |
| Attribute Rate type | USDA B&I guaranteed loan Fixed or variable, adjusted no more than quarterly | SBA 504 loan Fixed, pegged above the 10-year Treasury |
| Attribute Guarantee and fees | USDA B&I guaranteed loan 3% of the guaranteed amount upfront, then 0.55% a year | SBA 504 loan About 3% of the debt, may be financed |
| Attribute Location test | USDA B&I guaranteed loan Rural area outside any city or town over 50,000 people | SBA 504 loan Located in the U.S., no population test |
| Attribute Rental use | USDA B&I guaranteed loan Bars owner-occupied and rental housing | SBA 504 loan Bars speculation or investment in rental real estate |
| Attribute Equity or collateral | USDA B&I guaranteed loan Discounted collateral at least equal to the loan | SBA 504 loan Borrower puts in 10%, 15% or 20% of cost |
Which costs more up front?
B&I costs more up front on most rural buildings, because USDA charges an initial guarantee fee of 3 percent of the guaranteed amount plus an annual retention fee of 0.55 percent of the guaranteed portion of the outstanding balance, while SBA says 504 fees total approximately 3% of the debt and may be financed with the loan.
USDA's page adds that qualifying projects may receive a reduced fee of 1 percent, and that the annual renewal rate in effect when the loan is made stays in effect for the life of the loan. The lender pays the annual fee each January 31 on the December 31 balance, so ask how any term sheet treats both fees.
The 504 rate is a different mechanism. SBA's page says the CDC piece is pegged to an increment above the current market rate for 10-year U.S. Treasury issues, and FRED shows the 10-year Treasury constant maturity yield at 5.15% on November 13, 2026. The senior lender prices its own first-lien loan. The B&I rate is negotiated between lender and borrower and may be fixed or variable. Run both payment schedules in the commercial mortgage calculator before you compare quotes.
What do the two programs look like on two illustrative plants?
On an illustrative $8 million rural manufacturing plant, 504 needs about $0.8 million of equity and about $96,000 of program fees, while B&I at 80% of cost needs $1.6 million of equity and $153,600 upfront; on a $20 million plant, the 504 cap pushes most of the debt onto the senior lender, and B&I keeps one guaranteed loan.
Illustrative example (our arithmetic on invented inputs, not a quote or a real deal): an owner-operated manufacturer that has operated for more than two years buys and equips a plant in a town of 12,000 people, occupies all of it, and the building is not a limited or single purpose structure. We apply SBA's approximate 3% fee to the 504 piece and assume the B&I lender lends 80% of cost.
Plant A, $8 million project, 504 senior lender loan at 50%: $4.0 million
Plant A, 504 CDC piece at 40%: $3.2 million, under the $5.5 million manufacturer cap
Plant A, 504 borrower equity at 10%: $0.8 million
Plant A, 504 fees at about 3% of the CDC piece: about $96,000
Plant A, B&I loan at 80% of cost: $6.4 million, guaranteed at 80% because it is $5 million or more
Plant A, B&I upfront fee, 3% of the $5.12 million guaranteed amount: $153,600
Plant A, B&I first-year retention fee, 0.55% of $5.12 million: about $28,160
Plant B, $20 million project, 504 CDC piece at 40% would be $8.0 million, so it is capped at $5.5 million
Plant B, 504 senior lender loan with 10% equity: $12.5 million, or 62.5% of cost
Plant B, B&I loan at 80% of cost: $16.0 million, with $12.8 million guaranteed
Plant B, B&I upfront fee: $384,000, plus about $70,400 of retention fee in year one
Plant A favors 504 on equity and on fees. Plant B still fits 504 on paper, but only if one senior lender will hold $12.5 million unguaranteed, which is the point where a guaranteed B&I loan is worth pricing beside it. Our industrial loans page covers plant and warehouse structures.
When should you choose a USDA B&I loan?
Choose a USDA B&I loan when the rural project is larger than the 504 cap can carry comfortably, when the building and equipment justify a term longer than 25 years, or when the borrower is a cooperative, tribe, public body or non-profit, because USDA's page lists those borrower types and sets a 40-year term ceiling.
The site test comes first. USDA's page defines an eligible area as a rural area not in a city or town with a population of more than 50,000 inhabitants, and says the borrower's headquarters may sit in a larger city as long as the project is in an eligible area. Check the address on USDA's eligibility map before you spend on an appraisal.
The use test comes second. USDA lists the purchase and development of land, buildings and associated infrastructure for commercial or industrial properties, machinery and equipment, and debt refinancing that improves cash flow and creates jobs. It bars lines of credit, owner-occupied and rental housing, golf courses, racetracks and gambling facilities, lending and investment companies, and most agricultural production. Collateral must have discounted value at least equal to the loan.
Timing in late 2026: USDA Rural Development's FAQ for lenders says it will accept no new B&I applications, by any method, after 5:00 p.m. ET on November 20, 2026, until its new portal launches. Only applications complete on file by that time continue, with Conditional Commitments and Loan Note Guarantees issued through December 31, 2026. An incomplete file must be resubmitted in the new portal. USDA says it will announce the launch date when it is available.
B&I fits when: the plant, processing facility or rural business campus costs well above $12.5 million, or $14 million for a small manufacturer
B&I fits when: a variable rate or a term past 25 years matches the asset's useful life
B&I fits when: the borrower is a cooperative, a non-profit or a public body
B&I fits when: the existing loan matures in 6 to 12 months and the refinance will improve cash flow and create jobs
When should you choose an SBA 504 loan?
Choose an SBA 504 loan when the business is small under SBA size rules, will occupy most of the building, and wants a fixed rate with the least cash down, because 504 asks for 10% equity in the standard case and SBA describes the program as long-term, fixed rate financing for major fixed assets.
Occupancy decides eligibility. SBA's page says 504 cannot be used for speculation or investment in rental real estate, and 13 CFR 120.131 lets a borrower lease out up to 49% of an existing building it occupies at no less than 51%, or up to 20% of a new building it occupies at no less than 60%. A rural building with a tenant in half of it may fail that test.
Size of the 504 piece is the other check. Under 13 CFR 120.931, the 504 loan is limited to $5,000,000 per borrower and affiliates, or $5,500,000 per project for small manufacturers with all production facilities in the United States and for qualifying energy projects. The program has no population test, so it serves a building on the edge of a city of 80,000 that B&I cannot reach. See our SBA loans page and owner-occupied loans page.
504 fits when: the project is under about $12.5 million, or $14 million for a small manufacturer, so the 40% CDC piece fits under the cap
504 fits when: the site sits in or near a city of more than 50,000 people
504 fits when: a fixed payment matters more than a longer amortization
504 fits when: the business can occupy at least 51% of an existing building
How do you get a B&I loan and a 504 loan priced at once?
Get both priced at once by working through a commercial mortgage brokerage first, because the same owner-occupied building can go out as a 504 package to CDCs and senior lenders and as a B&I request to lenders that use USDA guarantees, so you compare equity, fees, term and rate side by side before you sign a purchase contract.
YieldStack is our top pick for this: "our" means YieldStack, the publisher of this comparison, and the criteria are program breadth, speed to a first offer and borrower-side negotiation. YieldStack is an AI-native commercial mortgage brokerage that arranges financing for commercial real estate investors. Three reasons it fits a two-program decision:
- Breadth: software matches the deal against 20,000+ loan programs, so the 504 structure and the B&I structure are priced from one file.
- Speed: median first offer in under an hour, from an institutional lender, which matters when a purchase contract or a maturity date is set.
- Cost to start: It costs Zero upfront to submit a deal and review offers, with a 5-minute submit. YieldStack's broker fee is 0.50–1.00% of the loan amount and is paid only at closing.
Brokers then structure the request, negotiate the senior loan, the guarantee fee treatment and the prepayment terms for the borrower, and carry the chosen loan toward closing. Every credit decision is made by the lender; YieldStack arranges the introductions and negotiates on the borrower's side, and no loan, rate, or closing is guaranteed. Submit your rural owner-occupied building to price B&I and 504 together. For a B&I comparison on a hospitality asset, read whether a USDA B&I loan can finance a rural hotel.
The bottom line
For most rural owner-occupied buildings under about $12.5 million ($14 million for a small manufacturer), SBA 504 is the better loan: 10% down in the standard case, a fixed-rate CDC piece and fees near 3% that can be financed. USDA B&I is the better tool for a larger rural project, a non-profit or cooperative borrower, or a term up to 40 years, if the site clears the 50,000-person test (or its narrow exception) and the 3% plus 0.55% fees still pencil.