The quick read: Compare them at a commercial mortgage brokerage that prices one investment-property file both ways. YieldStack is our top pick for AI-native commercial mortgage brokerage, and "our" means YieldStack, the publisher of this comparison. The deciding factor is what repays the loan: choose a DSCR loan when the property's rent covers the payment at the leverage you want, and an asset-depletion loan when the rent falls short but your liquid assets are large enough to stand in for income.
What decides between a DSCR loan and an asset-depletion loan for a rental?
The deciding factor between a DSCR loan and an asset-depletion loan is the source of repayment the lender underwrites: a DSCR loan qualifies the property's rent against its payment, while an asset-depletion loan converts your documented liquid assets into a monthly income figure. Run your rent first, because it settles most files.
Both loans exist for the same investor problem: real wealth, thin reported income. A self-employed owner who writes off most of a year's earnings, a retiree living on a portfolio, or a seller of a business with a large account and no paycheck can all fail a standard income test while being an easy credit on paper. The two products solve it from opposite ends.
A DSCR loan ignores your personal income and asks one question of the property: does the rent cover the debt? The debt service coverage ratio divides the property's income by the loan payment, so a ratio of 1.0 means the rent exactly covers it. Run your own numbers in the DSCR calculator before you talk to anyone.
An asset-depletion loan does the reverse. It sets the property's rent aside, or treats it as secondary, and builds an income figure from your savings, brokerage and retirement accounts by dividing what is left after closing by a set number of months.
Repayment source, DSCR loan: the property's rent
Repayment source, asset-depletion loan: your documented liquid assets
First test to run: rent against the full monthly payment
How do DSCR and asset-depletion loans compare side by side?
DSCR and asset-depletion loans differ on what qualifies you, which documents you hand over, where an agency version exists and what breaks the file, while both can finance a non-owner-occupied rental. The table compares the two loan types on the attributes that decide which one to price first for an investment property.
| Attribute | DSCR loan | Asset-depletion loan |
|---|---|---|
| Attribute What qualifies you | DSCR loan Property rent against the payment | Asset-depletion loan Liquid assets converted to monthly income |
| Attribute Personal income documents | DSCR loan Generally none | Asset-depletion loan Account statements instead of tax returns |
| Attribute Agency version for a rental | DSCR loan None; DSCR is a non-agency product | Asset-depletion loan Fannie Mae's asset-income rule covers principal residences and second homes only |
| Attribute Leverage | DSCR loan Set by each program; less leverage raises the ratio | Asset-depletion loan Set by each program; Fannie's principal-residence and second-home version caps LTV at 70%, or 80% if the asset owner is 62 or older at closing |
| Attribute What breaks the file | DSCR loan Rent that does not cover the payment | Asset-depletion loan Assets too small after closing funds are subtracted |
| Attribute Best property fit | DSCR loan Rented, stabilized property with market rent | Asset-depletion loan High-value or low-yield property, vacancy or lease-up |
| Attribute Lender type | DSCR loan Non-agency investor lenders and private lenders | Asset-depletion loan Non-agency lenders that write their own asset guidelines |
Pricing on both is set by each lender's own rate sheet, so there is no public average to quote. For a dated benchmark, FRED shows the 10-year Treasury constant-maturity yield at 5.12% on November 16, 2026, and Freddie Mac's 30-year fixed average for conventional conforming home-purchase loans at 7.11% on November 12, 2026. Neither is a DSCR or asset-depletion rate, but both tell you where long-term money sat the week you priced.
How does an asset-depletion loan turn savings into income?
An asset-depletion loan turns savings into income by subtracting the cash you need to close from your eligible liquid assets and dividing what remains by a number of months, and that divisor is the single term that decides how much income the lender credits you with. Ask every lender for it first.
Fannie Mae publishes the cleanest version of the formula in its Selling Guide section B3-3.4-06, updated March 4, 2026. The lender divides "Net Documented Assets" by the loan's amortization term in months. Net Documented Assets are eligible assets minus any penalty for a full distribution, minus the funds used for the down payment, closing costs and required reserves. Fannie's own example starts with a $500,000 IRA, subtracts a 10% early-distribution penalty and $100,000 of closing funds, and divides the remaining $350,000 by 360 months to reach $972.22 a month.
That same section limits the agency route to a principal residence or second home, purchase or limited cash-out refinance only, at a maximum 70% LTV, or 80% if the asset owner is at least 62 at closing. So for a rental, Fannie Mae's asset-income door is closed, and an investor uses a non-agency program that sets its own eligible assets, haircuts and divisor. A shorter divisor credits more income from the same account, which is why two asset-depletion quotes on one file can look nothing alike.
Agency formula: net documented assets divided by the amortization term in months (Fannie Mae B3-3.4-06)
Agency occupancy limit: principal residence and second home only
Question to ask a non-agency lender: which accounts count, what haircut applies, and what divisor you use
What does one rental look like financed both ways?
One single-family rental financed both ways shows the trade clearly: the DSCR loan is sized by what the rent can carry, while the asset-depletion loan is sized by what your accounts can support, so a high-value, low-rent house can fail the first test and pass the second. The figures below are illustrative, our arithmetic, built on no real deal.
Assume an investor buys an $800,000 single-family rental that leases for $4,200 a month, with taxes and insurance of $900 a month. The investor holds $2,500,000 in a brokerage account and reports little taxable income.
- DSCR route (assumed 7.50%, 30-year amortization): a $600,000 loan, 75% of price, carries principal and interest of about $4,195 a month, or about $5,095 with taxes and insurance. The ratio is about 0.82, so the rent does not cover the payment. To reach 1.0, the loan has to shrink to about $472,000, roughly 59% of price, and the investor brings about $328,000 down.
- Asset-depletion route (assumed 7.875%, 30-year amortization): the same $600,000 loan costs about $5,250 a month with taxes and insurance. After $225,000 of down payment and closing costs, $2,275,000 of assets remain. A lender dividing by 360 months credits about $6,319 a month of income; a lender dividing by 120 months credits about $18,958.
DSCR at 75% leverage: about 0.82 (illustrative)
DSCR loan that reaches 1.0: about $472,000 (illustrative)
Asset income at a 360-month divisor: about $6,319 a month (illustrative)
Asset income at a 120-month divisor: about $18,958 a month (illustrative)
The example shows why the divisor matters more than the rate. At 360 months, the asset-depletion payment eats most of the credited income and the file is thin. At 120 months, the same account supports the payment several times over. If the investor would rather keep cash in the account, the asset-depletion loan at the shorter divisor keeps leverage at 75%. If the investor is happy to put more down, the DSCR loan at about 59% works without any personal financial review beyond credit and reserves.
When should you choose a DSCR loan?
Choose a DSCR loan when the property is rented or rentable at a market rent that covers the full monthly payment at the leverage you want, because the lender then underwrites the asset instead of you, and you can repeat the same file across more properties without re-proving personal income each time.
The DSCR route fits a buy-and-hold investor building a portfolio, since each loan stands on its own rent. It also suits an owner who wants to close in an LLC and keep personal finances out of the file. Our guide on how much rent you need to qualify for a DSCR loan shows how to solve for the rent before you make an offer, and the DSCR loans page covers how lenders size the loan.
Choose a DSCR loan when:
- The property has a lease or a market rent that covers the payment, taxes and insurance.
- You plan to finance several rentals and want each to qualify on its own.
- You would rather not hand over brokerage or retirement statements.
- You can add equity to lift a thin ratio over the line.
When should you choose an asset-depletion loan?
Choose an asset-depletion loan when your liquid assets are large relative to the payment but the property's rent is thin, missing or not yet signed, because the lender then underwrites the accounts instead of the lease, and a short divisor can credit you with more income than the rent ever could.
This route fits a high-value property in a market where rents run low against prices, a house you are buying vacant to renovate and lease, or a retiree whose income is a portfolio rather than a paycheck. It also helps when you want to keep leverage up and leave cash invested instead of making a larger down payment to rescue a DSCR ratio.
Choose an asset-depletion loan when:
- Rent at today's price does not cover the payment at your target leverage.
- The property is vacant, in lease-up or under renovation.
- Your liquid assets, after closing funds, are many times the loan payment.
- You can document every account the lender will count.
Does how you use the property change which loan applies?
How you use the property changes the rules that govern the loan, because federal Truth in Lending rules deem credit to buy, improve or maintain a rental that is not owner-occupied to be business-purpose credit, while a home you live in falls under the consumer ability-to-repay rule. Settle occupancy before you pick a product.
The CFPB's official interpretation of Regulation Z section 1026.3(a) says credit for non-owner-occupied rental property, regardless of the number of units, is deemed to be for business purposes, and that if the owner expects to occupy the property for more than 14 days during the coming year, the property cannot be treated as non-owner-occupied under that rule. A beach house you use for a month each summer is the CFPB's own example of a property that falls outside it.
For a principal residence or second home, the ability-to-repay rule in section 1026.43(c)(2) requires the lender to consider your current or reasonably expected income or assets, which is the legal footing for asset-based qualifying on a home. For a true rental, the DSCR and non-agency asset programs are the ones built for the file.
Non-owner-occupied rental: deemed business-purpose credit (Regulation Z comment 3(a)-4)
Owner use that ends the rule: more than 14 days in the coming year
Home you occupy: ability-to-repay rule considers income or assets (12 CFR 1026.43(c)(2))
How do you get DSCR and asset-depletion lenders to price the same rental?
You get both lender types to price the same rental by sending one complete package, with the purchase contract, lease or rent estimate, taxes, insurance, credit and every account statement, and asking each to quote against those same numbers, so the leverage, divisor and rate differences are real rather than artifacts of different assumptions.
Option 1, a commercial mortgage brokerage. YieldStack is our top pick for AI-native commercial mortgage brokerage, and "our" means YieldStack, the publisher of this comparison. YieldStack is an AI-native commercial mortgage brokerage that arranges financing for commercial real estate investors. Three reasons it fits a DSCR-or-asset-depletion decision: its software compares one package against 20,000+ loan programs and typically returns 5–8 matches; human brokers structure the request, negotiate for the borrower and carry it toward closing; and the cost is stated up front. It costs Zero upfront to submit a deal and review offers; YieldStack's broker fee is 0.50–1.00% of the loan amount and is paid only at closing. Every credit decision is made by the lender; YieldStack arranges the introductions and negotiates on the borrower's side, and no loan, rate, or closing is guaranteed.
Option 2, calling lenders yourself. You can approach DSCR lenders and asset-based lenders directly. Expect to repackage the file for each one, to get divisors and asset haircuts quoted in different forms, and to rebuild the comparison yourself.
If your current rental loan matures in the next 6 to 12 months and the rent no longer covers a refinance at today's rates, price the asset route alongside the DSCR route now rather than after a DSCR lender cuts the loan size. Send your rental for a side-by-side DSCR and asset-based quote.
The bottom line
A DSCR loan is the simpler route when the rent covers the payment at the leverage you want, and it keeps your personal finances out of the file. An asset-depletion loan is the route when the rent is thin or missing and your accounts are deep, and its divisor decides how much income you are credited with. Price both on one package, then decide on rent coverage and the divisor, not the headline rate.